geopolitics
Should the U.S. strike Iran or pursue de-escalation?
Iran says it is counting the moments until it can attack U.S. warships, and Saudi Aramco facilities reportedly came under fresh attack overnight, CNBC reports.
Spar.
Spar.
Pick a topic, claim a side, go live. Takes about a minute.
Live cultural pulse
Should the U.S. strike Iran or pursue de-escalation?
Iran says it is counting the moments until it can attack U.S. warships, and Saudi Aramco facilities reportedly came under fresh attack overnight, CNBC reports.
Public activity
Loading public activity…
Loading public activity…
Should Trump rescind the Russian diesel deal?
Twelve senators, six Democrats and six Republicans, wrote asking Trump to withdraw from his recent deal with Putin, NPR reports.
Should SpaceX limit Starlink speeds in Ukraine?
Kyiv says overnight Starlink speed limits disrupted Ukrainian battlefield missions; SpaceX has not commented on the reported restrictions.
Is September's 3.7% inflation a policy failure?
CNBC reports consumer prices rose 3.7% annually in September, above the 3.6% Dow Jones forecast, as gas costs climbed.
Should PÖFF's Rebels section spotlight cancel culture?
The Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival's Rebels With a Cause lineup includes Dylan Stephen Levers' Pop Pop, which the festival says explores toxic masculinity and cancel culture.
Was OpenAI right to use its own AI to catch the suspect?
A Saudi engineer is charged with hiding a recorder in an OpenAI office; the company says its AI models traced the device to him.
Should Guilfoyle resign as US ambassador to Greece?
NPR reports Kimberly Guilfoyle was asked to resign as US ambassador to Greece over alleged pay-for-access.
Should Forensic Files return with 20 new episodes?
Radial Entertainment, Content Partners and ITV Studios plan 20 new Forensic Files episodes amid a streaming boom for vintage true crime, Variety reports.
Should Ukraine keep relying on Starlink for combat?
Ukraine says Starlink limits are disrupting military operations as Russia strikes energy infrastructure, per CNBC.
Was the $1.2B Treasury fine on Bank of America justified?
Bank of America shares fell 7% after a third-quarter revenue miss and a $1.2 billion Treasury fine, CNBC reported.
Does cancel culture do more good than harm?
Weigh public accountability against disproportionate punishment. Does cancel culture, overall, help society more than it hurts?
Should the NBA shorten its regular season?
Would fewer games improve the season enough to justify fewer dates for fans and teams?
Is NATO still necessary, or is it an outdated alliance?
NATO was built for the Cold War. After Ukraine, some say it's more vital than ever. Others argue it drags the US into conflicts that aren't its problem.
Should AI chatbots refuse to answer harmful questions?
A debate asks whether chatbots should decline harmful requests or answer them in the name of truth-seeking.
Can the NBA thrive after LeBron, Curry and Durant retire?
The next generation will need to earn its own audience. How much does a league depend on familiar stars?
Should powerful AI models be open or closed?
Open access offers scrutiny and experimentation; restricted access offers more control over use.
Can Apple compete with AI-first companies?
Is integrating AI into familiar devices a stronger strategy than focusing on standalone AI tools?
Should we be worried about AI consciousness and rights?
AI models can now hold conversations, write poetry, and express preferences. Are we getting closer to artificial consciousness, or is it all just very good pattern matching?
Should college athletes receive salaries?
Should college sports offer employment and salaries, or keep compensation outside an employment model?
Should smartphones be banned in schools?
Several states have banned phones in classrooms. Test scores improved in some districts. But is a ban treating the symptom instead of the cause?
Should AI firms keep renting compute from rivals?
OpenAI and Anthropic rent GPU clusters from Microsoft and Google, which also compete with them.
Should space exploration take priority over Earth?
How should limited public resources be split between space research and urgent needs at home?
Is the US global military presence essential or overreach?
An evergreen editorial premise asks whether the US military's worldwide base network and spending serve stability or amount to imperial overreach.
Is democracy still the best system of government?
Three centuries in, is one-person-one-vote the high water mark of governance — or are there better designs for an information-age society?
Should we merge with machines — implants, neural links, the works?
Transhumanism as the natural next step of evolution vs. drawing the line at the boundary of the human body.
Are we obligated to help future generations more than people alive today?
Longtermism's moral case for distant generations vs. the priority of people whose suffering is here and now.
Should a future society make work entirely optional?
Imagine basic needs can be met without everyone's labor. Should work be a free choice or a shared obligation?
Should we abolish prisons?
Restorative justice replacing punitive incarceration vs. the argument that some crimes still require separation from society.
Should we genetically engineer our children to be smarter and healthier?
The next generation of medicine could eliminate disease and boost capability — or could create a permanent biological underclass.
Does suffering make you stronger — or just damaged?
The Nietzschean view that adversity forges character vs. the modern view that trauma compounds and most pain is just pain.
Is the best future one where money disappears entirely?
A reputation/contribution economy without currency vs. money as the indispensable coordination tool of complex societies.
Should we live forever if we could?
Radical life extension as humanity's greatest achievement vs. mortality as the thing that gives life its weight.
Is loyalty more important than honesty?
Standing by your people no matter what vs. telling the truth even when it costs you everyone you love.
Are men and women fundamentally different — or mostly the same?
How much of what we see between the sexes is biology vs. how much is culture, and what we should build accordingly.
Is encryption that the government can't break a danger or a safeguard?
End-to-end encrypted everything as the last firewall against tyranny vs. as the tool that lets the worst actors operate freely.
Should lifelong commitment be the ideal for romantic love?
Love can deepen or change. Should lasting with one partner be the goal by which we judge relationships?